Lifestyle, Nutrition

What the Health: A critical viewpoint

what-the-health-critical-viewpoint

You’ve probably already watched it, and if not, at least heard of it – the latest screamingly pro-vegan documentary, called What the Health. It’s all over the place and, honestly, I was getting sick of seeing comments like: “The film opened my eyes and I became vegan overnight.”

I know it’s an extremely sensitive topic and everyone has something to say about it. What we need to keep in mind is that we all have the right to have our own opinions and views.

I had no intention to watch it, as I expected it would be pure propaganda. And what do you know – it was just that.

Despite that, I decided to keep an open mind and give it a chance. Fifteen minutes in and I was already feeling mentally abused.

What did What the Health get wrong?

I have several issues that screamed at me from the start:

1. Neither of the doctors or experts in the movie are introduced as pro-vegan, although they clearly are. Up until the end I was hoping to see an alternative opinion, a different view. You know – so that you can actually see both sides of the story and create your opinion based on the facts you hear. Instead, all you are offered throughout the movie are one-sided, biased opinions from selectively chosen people and cherry-picked studies to support an already set conclusion.

2. In the light of the Sugar industry scandals revealed in the past years, some of the openly pro-sugar arguments in What the Health strike me not only as absurd, but as incredibly suspicious as well.

What the Health might leave you with the impression that sugar is even good for you. Furthermore, the film makes no difference between sugars naturally presented in fruits, and, let’s say, the refined carbohydrates in a chocolate bar or the high-fructose corn syrup in a soda. There are tons of studies out there proving that the latter two are directly linked to an increased risk of several types of cancer, cardiovascular disease, Alzheimer’s and diabetes.

3. 

“I had no idea that what we ate affected cancer rates.

But I never felt like I had eaten a lot of processed meats until I realized that

processed meat includes hotdogs, bacon, sausage,

salami, ham, pepperoni, cold cuts and deli slices, basically everything

I grew up eating.”

This seemingly innocent statement from the star and co-director of the film Kip Andersen speaks volumes to me. Firstly, just before saying that he mentions being extremely health cautious even in his teen years. Given that, it is unexplainable to me how can a person 1) not make the connection between what you put in your body and your health and 2) not realize that bacon, sausages etc. are indeed processed meat. For me, even something as small as this puts a big question mark on the credibility of the documentary.

4. The film makes a lot of exaggerated, taken out of context and simply deceitful claims just to drive home their pro-vegan case. According to Anderson and his team eating processed meat is as harmful as smoking, eating an egg a day is as bad as smoking 5 cigarettes, milk causes cancer and fish is toxic. Let’s go over them quickly.



Firstly, comparing eating processed meat to one of the most detrimental habits known to human kind like smoking is simply absurd. Kip Anderson fails to understand (or purposefully miscommunicates) a very simple principle of classification that the World Health Organization’s International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) uses. While IARC does put processed meat and cigarettes together in Group 1 carcinogenic, this certainly doesn’t mean that both products are equally harmful.

Simply put, these categories show how strong the causal link between a product (a substance) and the risk of (certain types of) cancer is, but not by how much each different substance in that same category increases the cancer risk. Here’s a useful chart worth checking out. 

According to WHO review of available research, processed meat does increase the risk of cancer, mainly bowel cancer, but the health effects are not nearly as large as the ones from smoking. Another thing to keep in mind is that the risk increases predicated that you consume at least 50 grams of processed meat daily over an extended period of time.

Check out the graphic to get a better idea of the impact of smoking and processed meat on health.

Credit: Cancer Research UK
http://scienceblog.cancerresearchuk.org/2015/10/26/processed-meat-and-cancer-what-you-need-to-know/

Alright, one lie down. What about eggs? Is an egg a day really as bad as 5 cigarettes? Well, I’ve never heard of a single positive health effect coming from smoking, but there surely are boatloads of studies pointing out the health benefits of eggs. The yolk experienced some bad press because of its cholesterol content in the past, but numerous recent studies have conclusively proven that higher cholesterol intake doesn’t necessarily lead to a build up in the blood. In fact, the cholesterol in eggs can actually help to regulate the two different types of cholesterol in your body!

So that’s that. Moving on to whether or not milk causes cancer. Here again, Anderson chooses to cherry-pick single studies suggesting a link between milk consumption and cancer risk, and ignores a number of others  that either find no consistent link to mortality, or even indicating that dairy consumption is inversely and significantly associated with the development of breast cancer.

I’m guessing by this point you were thinking – “Okay, meat is out, eggs are out, dairy’s out, at least we have fish left, whew!” Oh, you wish. Kip Anderson is there to tell you that – what do you know – fish is toxic as well. Same as with eggs – there are tons of studies out there pointing out the numerous health benefits of fish, which I am sure you must have heard of – rich in omega-3 fats, vitamin D, selenium, low in saturated fat etc. What’s more, unlike sugar, fish like the wild caught salmon is loaded with anti-inflammatory compounds. So think twice, before cutting fish out of your diet.

What did What the Health get right?

So, after so many lies and deceitful claims, was there something that What the Health got right?

There are several points on which I can wholeheartedly agree with Kip Anderson.

  1. Conventional, factory-farmed meat is inflammatory and shouldn’t be a steady component of any diet. Furthermore, those factory farms often affect the environment and the communities around them in an extremely negative way.
  2. Big corporations and organizations use their money and power to influence studies and thus the dietary recommendations and health guidelines that people get.

Finally, I want to make clear that my goal is in no way to criticize a vegan diet, but to point out some obviously misleading and twisted claims in that specific film. What the Health’s one-size-fits-all approach to nutrition is something I strongly disagree with.  Each organism has its own uniqueness, and if one person thrives on a vegan diet, another one may suffer. In case you decide to keep animal products in your diet, make sure to buy organic, pasture raised products, ideally from local farms around you.

If there’s one thing you will take from this article, let it be to always be critical of what you read or hear, do your own research and take informed decisions.

21 Comments
Share

21 Comments

  1. Pramila
    October 22, 2017 at 5:30 pm

    Totally agree. Quality of food is really important. Vegan diet is point. For more health articles visit my site https://eurekaoflife.blogspot.com

  2. Lucien
    October 29, 2017 at 9:21 pm

    It’s onerous to find educated individuals on this subject, but you sound like you recognize what you’re speaking about! Thanks

    • Lily
      October 30, 2017 at 8:42 am

      Thank you, Lucien!

  3. Thabo makola
    November 17, 2017 at 8:12 pm

    Vegan diet is good for the blood type A’s due to theirs low acid content in the stomach and not good for other blood types , ie blood type O’s have high acid content and hence rely on proteins such as beef for survival.

  4. habib
    November 19, 2017 at 2:51 pm

    very nice post dear

  5. Thabo makola
    November 19, 2017 at 5:43 pm

    [email protected]

  6. Virjinia
    November 28, 2017 at 4:51 pm

    I couldn’t agree with this more. When this “documentary” came out, SO many people suddenly went Vegan without doing any research on this at all. I think we should all take a step back and do our own research to decide what’s best for us. Thanks for sharing!

    http://www.withpurposeandkindness.com

    • Lily
      November 30, 2017 at 1:44 am

      Yes, I hope that more people would follow this advice! Thanks for reading, Virjinia! 🙂

  7. Shelby @Fitasamamabear
    November 28, 2017 at 7:21 pm

    Thanks for the quick summary/points. I haven’t had a chance to watch it so this is helpful. I agree on the vegan thing though, don’t just “jump” into being vegan. Simmer, find what works for you (and your health) and move from there. One specific diet isn’t always right for everyone.

  8. Taylor
    November 28, 2017 at 10:28 pm

    I agree and believe its always about the quality food we eat. We don’t need to be vegan, we just need to focus on getting rid of all the unnatural processed foods and eat more of mother nature’s food. Great post.

    • Lily
      November 30, 2017 at 1:38 am

      Precisely! 🙂

  9. Ashish
    November 29, 2017 at 4:23 am

    Great points and summary. That documentary was full of outlandish claims that played to peoples emotions.

    • Lily
      November 30, 2017 at 1:42 am

      Thank you! And yes, this is what bothered me the most – it’s created with the intention to scare and misinform people.

  10. JOHN MULINDI
    November 29, 2017 at 10:53 am

    Everyone should take his or health serious and it all starts with the food you eat.

  11. Rye Santiago
    November 29, 2017 at 7:34 pm

    I haven’t seen the film so I’m in no position to critique it but, based on the passages you quoted from the documentary, I can understand how a documentary – which is supposed to enlighten people – can be much more detrimental than intended.

  12. Catherine
    November 29, 2017 at 9:37 pm

    I actually hadn’t heard of this yet! But now i want to go watch it to see what you are talking about!

  13. Christine
    November 30, 2017 at 12:39 am

    I agree that this was not the best film, but I have been seeing the vegan community flourish.

  14. Mel Parish
    December 6, 2017 at 2:13 am

    Nice review and retort I haven’t seen it but thanks for clarifying.

  15. Health Tutorials
    December 16, 2017 at 8:08 pm

    Very good write-up. I certainly love this website. Thanks!

  16. RED RIDING HOOD
    January 9, 2018 at 3:13 pm

    I eat eggs of my mother’s farm. She has 5 hens and feeding them with grass.

  17. Toni Caggiano
    January 9, 2018 at 5:27 pm

    I love this movie. But, I also love this post. I am a vegan. A lot of vegans are super pushy and want to get their ideas heard. But, I am totally of the opinion that what works for you is what works for you! You have to live your life the way you want to.

Reply your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*